PhiClaw vs Upfirst: AI Receptionist for a Medical Practice
Upfirst is an AI receptionist built for small businesses: plumbers, law firms, salons, and yes, some clinics. It answers calls, takes messages, and can book appointments. If you run a medical practice, the question is not whether Upfirst can answer a call. It is whether it can do so under HIPAA and finish the job in your EHR.
Upfirst in one paragraph
Upfirst bills per call, with public plans of about $24.95 a month for 30 calls, $59.95 for 90, $159.95 for 300, and $299 for 600, 20% off annually, and a 14-day free trial. Spam and very short calls are not billed. It supports 35+ languages. On HIPAA, third-party reviews disagree: some say Upfirst is not HIPAA compliant, others say a BAA is available only on its Custom plan. Ask Upfirst directly before any patient calls it.
Head to head
- Built for: Upfirst serves every small business. PhiClaw is built only for medical practices.
- BAA: Upfirst reportedly on the Custom tier only. PhiClaw on every plan.
- Pricing: Upfirst per call in buckets. PhiClaw's AI receptionist is $50 a month for your own local number, $0.19 a minute, 1¢ per text.
- Booking: Upfirst books into general calendar tools. PhiClaw books, reschedules, and confirms in your EHR, and works with 30+ major EHRs plus 300+ via Keragon.
- Medical questions: PhiClaw handles "Do you take Aetna?", sends intake forms, checks eligibility in payer portals, and routes clinical questions to staff.
What HIPAA actually requires
Under HIPAA, a medical practice can only hand protected health information (PHI) to a vendor that has signed a Business Associate Agreement (BAA). A BAA is the contract where the vendor promises to protect PHI, report breaches, and accept HIPAA obligations. Two details trip practices up: the BAA has to cover the exact product and plan you use, and it does not make you compliant by itself. You still need the right settings, access controls, and staff habits.
PhiClaw signs a Business Associate Agreement (BAA) with your practice and runs on HIPAA-eligible infrastructure, with BAAs in place with our subprocessors AWS (including Amazon Bedrock) and Convex. HIPAA-compliant calls run through our voice partner Retell AI, also under BAA.
What PhiClaw does differently
The phone is just the front door. PhiClaw is a HIPAA AI employee that answers the call and then texts the patient back, runs intake, scribes the visit, e-prescribes, bills, and follows up on no-shows. The receptionist add-on sits on top of the PhiClaw AI employee at $1,500 a month flat (4,320 questions/tasks included, unlimited users and locations, month-to-month), with a BAA on every plan.
When Upfirst is the right call
If your business is not handling PHI (for example a non-medical wellness studio) and you just want calls answered cheaply, Upfirst is a solid budget option. For a medical practice, insist on a BAA and EHR booking first.
Key takeaway: Upfirst is a cheap, multilingual AI receptionist for small businesses, but its BAA reportedly sits on the Custom tier and it does not book into medical EHRs. PhiClaw signs a BAA on every plan and books directly in your EHR.
Frequently asked questions
Is Upfirst HIPAA compliant?
Third-party reviews disagree. Some say it is not; others say a BAA is available only on Upfirst's Custom plan. Get a signed BAA from Upfirst before it handles any patient calls.
How much does Upfirst cost?
About $24.95 a month for 30 calls up to $299 a month for 600 calls, with 20% off on annual billing and a 14-day free trial, as of October 2026.
Can Upfirst book into my EHR?
Upfirst books into general scheduling tools. PhiClaw books, reschedules, and confirms directly in your EHR.
What does PhiClaw's AI receptionist cost?
$50 a month for your own local number, $0.19 a minute for calls, and 1 cent per text, as an add-on to the $1,500/month PhiClaw AI employee.
Does PhiClaw answer after hours?
Yes. PhiClaw answers 24/7, books the visit, and hands anything urgent to your on-call process.
Want a medical AI receptionist with a BAA on every plan?
PhiClaw signs a Business Associate Agreement (BAA) with your practice and runs on HIPAA-eligible infrastructure, with BAAs in place with our subprocessors AWS (including Amazon Bedrock) and Convex. HIPAA-compliant inbound and outbound calls are handled by our voice partner Retell AI, which is also under BAA.
Book a 20-min demo